Microsoft alleges Google, Motorola's Android phones infringe its mapping patent
Microsoft is suing Motorola Mobility in Germany over a mapping patentBy Loek Essers, Amsterdam | Friday, 12 October 2012
Microsoft is suing Motorola Mobility in Germany over a mapping patent that Microsoft alleges covers the Google Maps app that ships on Motorola phones. The two parties met each other in the regional court of Munich on Thursday, where Microsoft announced it would also sue Google over the same patent.
According to Microsoft, some products sold by Google-owned Motorola Mobility infringe on a patent that describes a method of obtaining the map from one database, resource information such as Starbucks locations from a second database, and overlaying the two sets of data. A technique like this is used in Google Maps, which is installed on Motorola's Android devices.
Microsoft sued Motorola Mobility and its German subsidiary. The lawsuit in the regional court of Munich started on Thursday with two hearings. During the hearings, Microsoft announced it would add Google as a defendant to the case, said a Microsoft spokeswoman in an emailed statement.
"It became necessary to add Google to this particular case because Motorola maintains that it lacks sufficient information about actions occurring on Google's servers," according to the statement.
This means that a possible verdict in favor of Microsoft could affect the entire Google Maps platform in Germany, according to patent-issues blogger and analyst Florian Mueller, who attended the hearing in Munich and reported about it on his blog. If Microsoft wins the lawsuit, the court would simply order Google not to infringe the claim, he said in an email. Mueller has been tapped as a consultant for tech companies including Oracle and Microsoft.
Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The mapping patent lawsuit was filed around the same time as Microsoft filed a number of other Android-related patent lawsuits against Motorola in Germany. It filed the suits because it wants Motorola to pay a licensing fee for Android. Microsoft has a licensing agreement with HTC, Samsung and most of the Android market that covers licenses to all Microsoft's Android-related patents. Motorola does not have a license and continues to infringe, according to Microsoft.
"We continue to hope Motorola will join the vast majority of Android device makers by licensing Microsoft's patented inventions," Microsoft said.
Microsoft already won three sales bans on Motorola devices in Germany for infringing a FAT file system patent, an SMS patent and a patent describing a method for handling communication between a keyboard and an application, while a fourth was denied in Mannheim last week.
One of the verdicts included a sales ban on the Motorola Atrix, the Droid Razr and the Droid Razr Maxx phones.
Motorola's device offerings in the German market are greatly reduced since the injunctions granted to Microsoft, and since a preliminary ban on sales of the Motorola Milestone XT720, the Motorola DEFY, the Motorola Atrix and Motorola XOOM granted to Apple in September.
At the moment, Motorola only offers two Android smartphones on its German website: the Razr i and the Razr HD. The only other phone listed on the site is the Gleam, a "classic clamshell phone", that uses a proprietary operating system. Visitors who click on the "tablet" tab are directed to a page that should list Motorola Android tablets, but right now the page just states "No results" in German.
Motorola did not respond to a request for comment.
"At the moment, Europe isn't a big priority for Motorola," said analyst Geoff Blaber of CSS Insight, who added that Motorola has said that that it would focus on fewer mobile devices.
"Motorola has been focusing on North America, Latin America and China," said Blaber.
- Allied Telesis axes NZ staff
- Express Data expands portfolio
- Brocade ANZ country manager talks OpenStack
- GeoOp expands with IT resellers
- NEC's 50 years in NZ
- Inhouse: Contract work, or reseller startup?
- Coffee Break with Luigi Cappel